Home & Kitchen

10 Best Electric Smokers Consumer Reports 2020 | Reviews

Barbecues and grills can be a tiring and dirty duty to do and for that reason, we often shift to a simpler, easier, and greater way of grilling — getting the best electric smoker. Electric smokers are just as great as grillers; they add that coveted smoked flavor and tender juicy goodness to meat. The only difference is that you don’t have to worry about ashes floating in the air and getting on you, and no smoky smelling clothes

Choosing the best electric smoker is not as easy as you may think. It’s not like you just go online and pick the cheapest one or simply go with the most number of likes and purchases.

You need to be more meticulous in choosing and you need to take your time in scrutinizing what features you’d prefer your electric smoker to have. We have narrowed down the list of 10 best electric smokers in the market today to make it easier for you to make a choice.

We will show you the benefits to their use, the items you’ll cook in them, and the way they will cause a lot of organized and fewer nerve-wracking parties.

List Of 10 Best Electric Smokers

Keep reading further to have a look at the buying guide as well where we have explained the most important things to consider when shopping for an electric smoker.

1. Char-Broil Deluxe Digital Electric Smoker

Char-Broil 17202004 Digital...
  • Insulated, double-wall construction
  • Advanced control panel with easy-read, blue...
  • Removable food thermometer
  • Glass door and stainless steel, dual-tone...

Char-Broil is probably best known for their barbecues, but as this smoker shows, they are capable of producing a smoker that is good enough to be featured on our best electric smoker review list. 

The Char-Broil Deluxe smoker features the locking latch with a smoke-tight seal, which ensures that both the flavor and smoke remain inside. Also featured is a removable temperature gauge, advanced control panel, and a blue LED display. This smoker also comes with an integrated handle and wheels, both of which allow for easy mobility.

This electric smoker will appeal to those who frequently throw parties for large groups of people. It has a total of 725 square inches of cooking space with over 4 different cooking grates, which is more than enough space to cook up for a great party. It also has a warming feature that keeps your food warm until it’s ready to be served.

For starters, it is an extremely well-constructed electric smoker. The walls of the appliance are made out of very thick steel. This double-wall construction makes this electric smoker a whole lot more durable.

PROS
  • Good cooking power
  • Double-walled construction keeps heat in
  • Solid stainless-steel exterior
  • Glass door for easy viewing
  • Aesthetically appealing with dual tone finish
CONS
  • Customer service needs to ramp up to the needs of their customers
  • Temperature control is off
  • No batteries come with the remote

2. Smoke Hollow 26142E 26-Inch Electric Smoker

Smoke Hollow 26142E 26-Inch...
  • Includes 1500-watt heating element with fully...
  • Two (2) chrome-plated cooking grids are...
  • Full range heat indicator
  • Side handles and cool-touch spring wire door...

The Smoke Hollow 26 Inch is an ideal smoker for outdoor cooking, and it can be used to smoke veggies, meat, and much more. It comes with a fully modifiable electric heating element with three temperature settings and an external temperature gauge that keeps your smoker at a consistent temperature.

The 2 chrome-plated cooking racks have several adjustable levels that can cook around 5 pounds of meat. Furthermore, included is the porcelain coated water pan and chip tray. 

With a weight of 34.9 pounds and 2 side handles, this electric smoker is very easy to use and highly portable.

Overall, the Smoke Hollow Electric Smoker is a great device for small barbecues or a large family.

PROS
  • Has multiple adjustable levels
  • Varying temperature settings
  • Has 2 side handles that come in handy during transportation
  • Easy to assemble and use
  • Overall compact design
CONS
  • Ridiculously short warranty
  • Leaks smoke & grease

3. Bradley BTDS76P Digital 4 Rack Electric Smoker

Bradley Digital 4 Rack Electric Smoker is perfect for entertaining guests by creating gourmet foods in your own home and enjoying the flavor that the smoke brings. It makes tender and juicy meat with a coveted smoked flavor.

This is one BBQ electric smoker that makes barbecue and sausages to die for with a temperature controllable up to 320 degrees Fahrenheit.

It comes with four detachable racks that can hold up to 20 pounds of meat. That’s a decent amount of food cooking and roasting to perfection, right? You can throw a great barbeque party for friends and family without worrying to run out of food at the last moment.

One downside to this electric smoker is the poor insulation which is not sufficient to combat the effects of the external temperature. So if you live in an extremely cold environment, then this might not be the best option for you.

PROS
  • Huge capacity
  • One year warranty from date of purchase
  • Internal thermostat
  • Four fully supported, removable racks
  • Easy to clean
  • Screams luxury and class
CONS
  • Expensive
  • Sub-par insulation

4. Smokehouse Products Little Chief Front Load Electric Smoker

Sale
Smokehouse Products Little...
  • Front loading electric smoker comes with...
  • Consistent low temperature setting using a...
  • Easy-slide chrome-plated grills; maximum...
  • Durable, embossed aluminum construction; for...

One reason why we love electric smoker grills is because they make us feel like expert chefs in just a matter of prepping and simply waiting. This outside electric smoke griller is great because it does everything and even more than the typical griller. It has great insulation that locks in the heat and allows an even cooking throughout your barbecue if you are willing to use it as a slow cooker.

It can cook up to 25 pounds of food and has only one temperature set to 165 degrees Fahrenheit. This is a high temperature and is enough to cook your food. It doesn’t have any other adjustments to set the temperature higher or lower to adjust the cooking time that is why you need to calculate just how much time it would cook a certain slab of meat depending on its thickness.

It also provides good and easy clean-up with the removable drip tray and the sleek stainless steel interior. However, with smaller size — as defined by its name — it cannot cook enough meat for a big crowd. Still, this is a great electric smoker, especially for beginners.

It is the cheapest electric smoker in the market today and comes with a 2-year warranty. You also lots of free stuff with this machine. This includes a bag of Chips ‘n’ Chunk history flavor wood fuel and instruction booklet.

PROS
  • Super easy to clean & maintain
  • Lightweight
  • Highly portable
  • 2 years warranty
CONS
  • Not suitable for large gatherings
  • Only one temperature set

5. Masterbuilt MB 20070910 30 Inch Digital Electric Smoker

Masterbuilt MB20071117 Digital...
  • Digital panel controls on/off, cooking...
  • Four chrome-coated smoking racks
  • Patented side wood chip loading system allows...
  • Thermostat-temperature control for even,...

Masterbuilt Electric Smokers finest quality is that it leaves the meat moist, crisp on the outside, and outstanding to the taste buds.

It has a temperature range that starts from 100 to 275 degrees Fahrenheit. The temperature is digitally controlled so it is constant. It also has an automatic shut-off so that you are left with perfectly cooked meat. So say no more to dry and overcooked meals with the Masterbuilt 20070910. We love that it is well-insulated. You won’t ever feel any heat leaking out.

It is as big as a mini-refrigerator but because it has four chrome-coated racks, you can cook about 30 pounds of meat inside. That’s enough to feed a large crowd of guests on special occasions. 

It also features a removable water pan; you can add spices, vinegar, and cider, or other things to spice up your meal. The heat can infuse the spices into your smoky meat adding flavor and depth to your food.

We love that it has a digital controller on top. Unfortunately, it can only go as high as 275 degrees Fahrenheit which may not be such a great temperature in cooking a huge amount of meat. The only thing we dislike about this is the size of the cooking rack.

PROS
  • 800-watt heating elements allows for even and consistent smoking
  • Side wood chip loading mechanism
  • Sturdy door latch to prevent smoke from leaking
  • Integrated meat probe thermometer
  • Ample cooking space
CONS
  • Small size of the cooking rack

6. Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker

Char-Broil Analog Electric...
  • 544 Square inches of cooking space spread...
  • Double-wall insulated construction with dual...
  • Door-mounted temperature gauge, and dual...
  • Front-access water tray, grease cup and wood...

Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker is a great roaster, griller, and smoker. It smokes everything you put into a T.

The 1000 watt heating element installs easily along with a controller that allows for direct temperature adjustment. The door includes a mounted temperature gauge for reading the internal temperature, as well as dual latches for ensuring proper moisture and heat in the cooking chamber.

The three trays for meats, fish, and poultry can be adjusted according to your preference. There is a large cooking surface area and enough capacity to throw a huge barbeque party at your home.  

A stainless steel locking latch seals the smoker tight and you get great ribs, and other food smoked to a great flavor in record time.

The drip tray catches the grease and leaves to make cleanup quick and easy. The dual side exhaust ports provide improved temperature consistency.

PROS
  • Affordable
  • Dual exhaust ports provide Improved heat consistency
  • Rock-solid construction
  • Great smoked taste at a good price
  • Large cooking surface area
CONS
  • No viewing window
  • Handle to open the door is absent

7. Bradley Technologies Original 6 Rack Smoker Stove

Bradley Technologies Original...
  • Automatic bisquette advancement
  • Stainless Steel interior
  • Smoke for up to 8 hours without adding...
  • Bisquette burner is separate from oven...

The Bradley Smokers Grill makes the perfect evenly smoked meat. The stainless steel interior can cook up your food like an oven since it also has great heat insulation inside. It just makes the smokiness stick to the innermost slices of meat.

It comes with four detachable racks that can hold up to 20 pounds of meat. That’s a decent amount of food cooking and roasting to perfection. It has great temperature control, retention, and the temperature doesn’t change throughout the cooking process.

It has a nice looking wood chips feeder over the controller, what’s great about it is that it is economical on wood chips but does a great job in providing smoke good enough to add flavor to a full outdoor smoker. It has a separate smoke generator; this saves you the trouble of constantly opening your smoker.

It looks great by the way. It looks like a mini-fridge with an extension for the woodchips generator but it adds an appeal to the backyard. It can even be used as a tabletop electric smoker. This automatic smoker is pretty tough too especially if you take effort in caring for it.

PROS
  • Easy to set up and use
  • Easy temperature control
  • Heavy-duty magnetic door
  • Stainless steel interior
  • Sufficient cooking space
CONS
  • Bisquettes designed for this electric smoker are not budget-friendly
  • Sub-par insulation

8. Smokin-It Model #1 Electric Smoker

Smokin-It Model #1 Electric...
  • Up to 22 lbs. of meat capacity per load
  • 400 watt heating element, 8 amps 120 volt...
  • 3" Diameter rubber casters and 3 removable...
  • All 201, 18 ga. stainless steel construction....

The Smokin-It Model #1 Electric Smoker happens to be a decent electric smoker because of its exceptional portability. As you will see in this review, the Smokin-It manages to deliver surprisingly good performance, all while remaining relatively small.

Powered by a 120 volts 8 amp unit, a 400-watt heating element and enough space to roast 22 pounds of meat at a go, Smokin-It Model #1 Electric Smoker is, without doubt, remarkable equipment. The portability of the smoker is enhanced by its properties and features; weighs 59 pounds, has side handles for easy lifting and wheels for uneven terrain. The smoker comes with three shelves and rheostat to control temperatures of maximum of 250 degrees Fahrenheit.

It is shaped sort of like a mini-refrigerator; it is a large square, as opposed to being shaped like a cabinet.

PROS
  • Relatively compact and portable
  • Thick walls are both durable and capable of keeping the heat in the smoker
  • Decent-sized cooking area
  • Wheels for added mobility
CONS
  • Might be a bit too small for people who want to cook really large volumes of food at once

9. Landmann Smoky Mountain 26″ Electric Smoker

LANDMANN MCO 32954 Landmann...
  • 3-in-1 combination tray
  • Non-insulated cooking chamber
  • Product is 26 inches

Enjoy the delight of viewing your barbeque as it cooks with this smoker. The Smoky Mountain Electric Smoker has double doors and a viewing window.

It also features adjustable legs suiting rough terrain. This smoker boasts of an expansive cooking area of 440 square inches. It has a remarkable 3 in 1 tray that ensures easy access during cleaning. Further, the smoker has a temperature controller that may be plugged in.

It cooks the turkey with smoke and gives it a great smoked flavor. This makes for excellent dishes that make a family want to sit up and take notice.

PROS
  • Easy to use & clean
  • Very affordable
  • Viewing window allows easy monitoring
  • 1500 watts of power makes it great for smaller cuts of meat and sausages
CONS
  • Weak magnetic door

10. Old Smokey Electric Smoker

Old Smokey Electric Smoker
  • Color: Grey
  • Size: 15.5"w x 15.5"d x 29"h
  • This smoker has a flat top, so juices drip...
  • On top of the heating element is a chip tray...

The Old Smokey Electric Smoker possesses a unique design but the ease of use makes it an exceptional electric smoker in the market. It has a heating element just like an electric oven. It measures 29 x 15.5 x 15.5 inches and weighs a mere 24 pounds, making it very portable.

The smoker has a solid build of steel making it durable and a flat top that ensures the barbeque retains all its sweetness. The upper cooking level has an extra grill making it very convenient. It features a heat thermostat, which shuts down on its own when the meat is cooked making it highly efficient.

Although the cooking area is small, it can easily make 4 chickens to a T with the juicy tenderness and smoked flavor. One downside to this electric smoker is the circular shape that makes it difficult to clean and add wood chips. But overall, this is a good option to buy an electric smoker if you are not willing to spend a chunk of money.

PROS
  • Easy to set up and move with
  • Has a remarkable heat distribution
  • Durable
  • Solid construction with a flat top
  • Budget-friendly
CONS
  • Difficult to clean
  • Difficult to add wood chips

Factors to Consider when Buying an Electric Smoker

Before you make a choice on the right electric smoker for you, it is helpful to understand what facets you are looking at with regard to the technology behind it. These are the most important factors to consider when shopping for an electric smoker:

User-friendly

Compared to charcoal smokers, electric smokers are by far a lot easier and friendlier to use. This is because they do not require a lot of manual effort to light and use. Even if you’re new to smoking, with so many automatic features, you should get great results on how your food cooks and smokes, practically on auto pilot.

The Manufacturer

Evaluating the manufacturer of the product is simple. Some have better reputations than others. It is also helpful to read product reviews.

Temperature Control Feature

You’ll find that there are two different types of electric smokers when it comes to the ability to adjust the temperature. Some have temperature control via thermostats while others have rheostats.

Thermostats will shut off the power until the minimum temperature is reached whereas rheostats adjust temperature constantly to maintain it. You’ll find that thermostat-controlled electric smokers are more efficient when it comes to energy use because there are fewer fluctuations (e.g., it’s either on or off).

Price

The lowest-priced electric smoker might attract your eyes and pocket but keep in mind that the low price means that the electric smoker is deficient in certain aspects and that the overall product is lacking something. Trust me, you don’t wanna buy something that doesn’t include warranty, easy to use features, and poor construction.

Features

Modern electric smokers come with a host of features, including sensors, time settings, cooking mode, and temperature settings. Generally, the more the number of features, the higher the price of an electric smoker. Therefore, it’s good to recognize the function of each of the features and only purchase a model with the features you actually need and will use.

Capacity/Unit Size

The size or capacity of a smoker is another crucial aspect of consideration. Don’t over-buy. It’s easy to get excited about the large, grand-looking smokers. If you’re a regular entertainer, then a big electric smoker with a higher capacity might be right for you. Alternatively, if you are looking for a smoker that you can use to prepare meals for you and your family, you can go for a smoker with a smaller capacity.

Energy Conservation Features

As much as electric smokers are cost-efficient in the long run, it is important for you to choose one that comes with energy conservation features. This will help to save energy.

Conclusion

With only 10 of the best electric smokers on our list, we are sure you’d love to have any of these in your house. In fact, you can even add them to your list of father’s day gifts this year. As long as there is a meathead in the family, they are bound to be extremely happy with your pick.

It can easily become a necessity in every household because all you need to do is plug in the smoker and select the temperature. It will cook your meat at your chosen temperature without any more work from you. Since your electricity is always ready for you, you won’t have to drive to buy more fuel, like wood and charcoal. That will always delay and maybe even ruin your dinner plans for that day.

So far we have loved our choices and have considered a lot of factors in picking them out. We are sure that your pick is just as great as ours. You might love to have your pre-barbecued delight when you are going camping with your family. So, take your pick and enjoy every bit of meal that your new electric smoker will serve on your table.

Join The Discussion